Instagram and Snapchat both made numerous changes since they launched five years and four years ago, respectively, but they are still among the most stripped-down, simple social apps available. And neither of them lacks users, growth or popularity.
[Related Feature: Social messaging apps struggle with decision to bundle or unbundle]
Instagram is now the second largest social network in the United States behind Facebook (which owns Instagram), having surged past Twitter, with more than 400 million monthly active users (MAU). The photo-sharing app hit 200 million MAUs in March 2014, then passed 300 million MAUs in December 2014 and recently hit 400 million MAUs in late last month.
While some of the older, and seemingly more established, social networks such as Twitter continue to pack new features into their platforms, the usage results show that people want simpler social experiences instead of a labyrinths of buried options.
[Related News Analysis: Facebook's future could include app consolidation]
"If there is a simple app that becomes popular those features are easily reproduced," says Brian Blau, research director, Gartner. The value of a social network's brand can quickly degrade under such circumstances, Blau says, which is one reason why there's so much pressure on these companies to increase functionality.
"If they have some amount of growth and trajectory they'll probably be hesitant to add too many features because they want to keep those core users engaged as long as possible," says Blau. "The strategy is that after you gain these users, you can sort of push the features and functionality as much as you want, but eventually you're going to have to add more services and that usually means adding more apps."
It's difficult to clearly state the benefits of simplicity versus a breadth of features in social networks, because some of the most simple apps are slowly becoming more complex. "Snapchat is a great example," says David Berkowitz, CMO of creative and technology agency MRY.
Snapchat was initially a private messaging app. The company since added "Stories," or collections of posts that last for 24 hours, and a "Discover" entertainment section that includes content specifically produced for the platform by major media companies. Snapchat now sees more than 4 billion video views each day, putting it on pace to overtake Facebook in the coming months.
[Related News Analysis: Snapchat on pace to overtake Facebook for video supremacy]
Instagram evolved much more quickly, according to Berkowitz. "It's still about sharing photos, though looking at threads of comments to posts from popular photographers there, it often feels more like a rambling message board than a photography app," he says.
Instagram added video a little more than two years ago, and its private messaging feature came soon after, in an effort to compete with Snapchat and other popular messaging apps. Apps such as WeChat, Kik, Line, Facebook Messenger and others, which started out as simple text, photo and video sharing services, eventually added a wide range of features, including gaming, ecommerce, event planning, news and more, according to Berkowitz.
Very few apps get more streamlined over time, he says. "Instead, it seems that every time an app posts an update in the App Store or Google Play, it's adding some new feature."