Congress eyes commission to tackle encryption debate
Sen. Mark Warner, D-Va., and Rep. Michael McCaul, R-Tex. plan to discuss their joint legislative proposal to create a Digital Security Commission later today, according to aides. McCaul is the chairman of the House Homeland Security Committee; Warner is a member of the Senate's Select Committee on Intelligence, among other committees.
A major focus of the commission will be encryption technology used in smartphone apps and elsewhere and how intelligence officials can legally monitor encrypted communications used by terrorists to plan attacks. Both lawmakers have written about how encryption poses a paradox for protecting both security and personal privacy.
The idea for a Digital Security Commission stems from concerns voiced by the FBI and others after the attacks in Paris and San Bernardino last year. FBI Director James Comey told a Senate hearing in December that one of two terrorists killed in a May 3, 2015 attack in Garland, Texas had used encrypted messages 109 times before staging that attack.
Comey and lawmakers and even President Obama have repeatedly asked technology companies to voluntarily find ways to turn over to a judge any encrypted communications suspected of being terrorist related. Those requests have brought strong opposition from privacy advocates.
Apple CEO Tim Cook, among others in the tech community, has openly defended personal privacy, noting that newer Apple iPhones protect personal data with encryption directly on the phones that can't be accessed by anybody but the user.
The two lawmakers jointly penned an opinion piece for The Washington Post last month that outlined their intentions. "Because extremists are 'going dark,' law enforcement officials warn that we are 'going blind' in our efforts to track them," they wrote.
They noted that ISIS has distributed a manual to followers that includes tips for concealing messages through end-to-end encryption, secure apps and other means. Similar tactics are used by drug traffickers and child predators, they said.
But the lawmakers also admitted that encryption is also a "bedrock of global commerce and it has helped enhanced individual privacy immeasurably."
They added: "Digital innovations present us with a paradox. We are no longer simply weighing the costs and benefits of 'privacy vs. 'security' but rather 'security vs. security.'" Mandating backdoor access to encrypted data would "weaken Internet privacy for everyone" and make "information systems more vulnerable to attack."
McCaul and Warner want the new commission to include experts on all sides of the debate from technology, the legal world, academia and law enforcement. "This would not be a group of politicians debating one another," they wrote, but would be a body charged with developing "actionable recommendations that can protect privacy and public safety.
"We must find more ways to stop terrorist attacks during the planning phase -- not while they are under way," they wrote.